Home/Journal/The Edit/Secondhand Luxury: Value in Knitwear and Outerwear
The edit
The edit - Live on eBay

Secondhand Luxury: Value in Knitwear and Outerwear

Six live listings in knitwear and outerwear, and what the gap between each asking price and each label says about how resale actually prices sizing and sub-labels.

6 Aug 20264 min

Most of the discounts in this group are not condition discounts. Nothing here is damaged or obscure, and three of the six are Burberry. What they have in common is that they sit in the parts of the market where buyer demand thins out for reasons that have nothing to do with the garment: large sizes, discontinued diffusion lines, and coats that are expensive to ship and awkward to store.

That is a useful pattern to hold onto, because it is repeatable. A label's mainline pieces get bid up by people searching the brand name alone. Its retired sub-labels, its XLs, and its bulkier outerwear get found by people who already know what they are looking at, and there are fewer of those people.

The risk in this territory is different too. When the discount comes from demand rather than damage, the thing to check is fit and wear, not authenticity or repair. Each note below points at the specific thing worth confirming before you commit.

1
Eileen Fisher Womens Red Marled Wool Mohair Cashmere Open Front Cardigan XL
Eileen Fisher
Eileen Fisher Womens Red Marled Wool Mohair Cashmere Open Front Cardigan XL
$60 vs $348 retail 83% below
A marled red open-front cardigan in a wool, mohair and cashmere blend, cut loose by design. The XL is doing most of the work on the price here: Eileen Fisher's larger sizes sit longer on resale, though the yarn and the make are identical across the size run. Mohair blends pill at the cuffs and underarms before anywhere else, so ask for close photographs of both.
2
CHRISTIAN DIOR Paris Metallic Silver Cap Sleeve Wrap Dress 10 Silk Cocktail
Dior
CHRISTIAN DIOR Paris Metallic Silver Cap Sleeve Wrap Dress 10 Silk Cocktail
$400 vs $3,500 retail 89% below
Silk, metallic silver, cap sleeve, listed at a US 10. A wrap dress carries its own waist adjustment, which makes it one of the safer categories to buy without trying on, since a size out either way is usually recoverable at the tie. The exception is silk under the arms, where old perspiration marks are permanent and often invisible in a hanging photograph.
3
Burberry London Brown Gray Plaid 2Button Side Vents Wool Jacket Coat 40 R
Burberry London
Burberry London Brown Gray Plaid 2Button Side Vents Wool Jacket Coat 40 R
$134 vs $1,095 retail 88% below
This is a Burberry London piece, one of the sub-labels the house ran alongside the mainline before consolidating everything under a single Burberry name in 2016. Retired sub-labels are the clearest example of the pattern above: the garment did not change, but the name no longer matches what buyers type into the search box. At a 40 R with side vents, it is a tailored jacket rather than a coat, so it wants a shirt and a knit under it, not a suit.
4
Burberry London Womens Toggle Duffle Coat Black Wool SZ 10 R England Made Luxury
Burberry
Burberry London Womens Toggle Duffle Coat Black Wool SZ 10 R England Made Luxury
$150 vs $1,095 retail 86% below
Duffles are the least liquid coats on the secondary market. They are heavy to ship, they take up a shelf rather than a hanger, and the silhouette is unambiguous in a way that a plain overcoat is not, all of which thins the buyer pool without touching the quality of the thing. On a duffle the toggles and their leather or cord loops are the first point of failure, so confirm they are all present and that none are stretched.
5
W120 VINCE 100% CASHMERE SHOULDER SLIT WOMEN SWEATER SIZE XL $345
Vince
W120 VINCE 100% CASHMERE SHOULDER SLIT WOMEN SWEATER SIZE XL $345
$70 vs $320 retail 78% below
Full cashmere, XL, with a slit at the shoulder. Vince sits in the band where the fibre costs more than the name does, which means at this price you are essentially paying for the yarn and getting the label thrown in. The shoulder slit is a design detail rather than a fit adjustment, so it will not add room across the chest if the XL is running close.
6
Burberry Brit Black Trench Coat Size US 2
Burberry
Burberry Brit Black Trench Coat Size US 2
$145 vs $745 retail 81% below
Brit was the younger of the retired sub-labels, and it turns up secondhand far more often than the mainline does simply because far more of it was made. A US 2 is the constraint worth thinking about: trench coats are cut to be layered over tailoring, so a small size in this shape is genuinely small rather than roomy. Get the shoulder and sleeve measurements flat before you bid, since a trench that is tight through the back cannot be let out.

If you are buying from this group, sort by what you can verify from photographs. Knitwear shows its history at the cuffs and underarms, coats show theirs at the lining and the closures, and neither is visible in a listing title. Ask the seller for those shots before the auction closes rather than after.

Shop women's deals → Shop men's deals →