Eileen Fisher Tops

Eileen Fisher tops turn up secondhand in volume, which makes the sorting worth doing. The silk-jersey and heavier knit pieces hold their shape over years; the lighter Tencel and modal blends soften and drape out faster than most buyers expect. Both sell at similar prices, so knowing which fabric you're looking at is most of the work.

3 pieces curated featuring Eileen Fisher

Showing

Eileen Fisher Organic Cotton Long Sleeve Shirt Blue Size Small 3415

97.1% · 65 ratings Free shipping Listed 1 month ago

Eileen Fisher's organic cotton shirt—the washable basic that made the brand a reference point for mindful, well-made wardrobe staples.

10.0 /10

Eileen Fisher $40 $128–$168$168(73% Off Est. Retail73% Off Est Retail)

Eileen Fisher Black 100% Silk Jersey Turtleneck Top Sz Large Long Sleeve Classic

100.0% · 2,987 ratings Free shipping Listed 1 month ago

Eileen Fisher's signature silk jersey—the fabric that built her reputation for polish without fuss—here where the brand's smaller resale following leaves room between retail footprint and secondhand attention.

10.0 /10

Eileen Fisher $40 $198–$278$278(83% Off Est. Retail83% Off Est Retail)

Eileen Fisher Womens Small Shirt Tank Top Silk Flowy Quiet Luxury

99.3% · 8,426 ratings Free shipping Listed 3 months ago

Eileen Fisher's washed-silk tank is cut generous through the bust—size down if you want it closer, or let it drape as intended.

7.0 /10

Eileen Fisher $40 $158–$198$198(78% Off Est. Retail78% Off Est Retail)

No deals match your filters.

Try broadening your search, or run a new search to surface more picks.

Buying Secondhand Eileen Fisher Tops

The brand's tops span a wider range of fabrics than the consistent design language suggests, and they don't age at the same rate. Fibre content in the listing tells you more than the photos do, and the intended fit is loose enough that the size label is close to meaningless on its own.

Silk Jersey and Heavy Knits Outlast the Lighter Blends

The silk-jersey shells and tanks are the most durable thing in this part of the range — the fabric has enough weight to keep its line and doesn't develop the limp drape that lighter blends do. Heavier merino and cotton-blend knit tops behave similarly. The Tencel, modal, and lyocell blends are comfortable and photograph well, but they soften with washing and lose their shape at the neckline sooner. Both types sell secondhand at similar prices, so reading the fibre content is the single most useful thing you can do before buying.

The Size Label Is Not the Fit

Eileen Fisher cuts deliberately generous, and a small is not shaped like a conventional small. Buyers unfamiliar with the brand often size up unnecessarily and end up with far more fabric than they wanted. Go by the flat chest and length measurements instead. On condition, the places to look are the neckline for stretching and distortion, the underarms on anything pale, and the hem on boxy styles, where the weight of the fabric can pull unevenly if the piece has been hung rather than folded.