Theory Dresses

Theory dresses are among the more affordable name-brand dresses secondhand, and they turn up often in good shape. The jersey and crepe styles are the workhorses -- easy to read for condition -- and as with Theory's tailoring, a named fabric on the label beats a generic stretch blend.

11 pieces curated featuring Theory

Showing

Theory Lewie Dress Womens S Black Silk Crew Neck Sleeveless Tank Maxi Lined

100.0% · 6,612 ratings +$8 shipping Listed 18d ago

Theory's silk-tank maxi cut in a crew neck that reads office-to-evening, recently listed at a price that undercuts where the brand's dresses usually settle.

10.0 /10

Theory $65 $345–$445$445(84% Off Est. Retail84% Off Est Retail)

Theory Eco Crunch Scoop Neck Sleeveless Midi Dress Black XL

100.0% · 237 ratings +$10 shipping Listed 1 month ago

Theory's Eco Crunch fabric -- a textured weave that reads as workwear but wears like a uniform -- in a cut that sits between office and evening.

10.0 /10

Theory $75 $295–$395$395(78% Off Est. Retail78% Off Est Retail)

Theory Gray Sleeveless Sheath Dress Geometric Knee Length Size 10

100.0% · 14 ratings Free shipping Listed 4 months ago

Theory's stretch-wool sheath—the cut that built the brand's reputation on boardroom tailoring—here with a couple weeks of seller patience already behind it.

7.0 /10

Theory $60 $295–$345$345(81% Off Est. Retail81% Off Est Retail)

Theory Leopard Print Silk Georgette Asymmetrical Maxi Slip Dress Sz 2 Fairygrung

99.8% · 3,129 ratings Free shipping Listed 8 months ago

Theory's bias-cut slips run long—this asymmetrical hem will skim the ankle on anyone under 5'6", and the leopard silk georgette is a niche the brand executed precisely but few shoppers search for.

7.0 /10

Theory $70 $395–$445$445(83% Off Est. Retail83% Off Est Retail)

Theory Apalia Dress 8 Black White Zip Front A-Line Short Sleeve Zip Pockets

99.4% · 774 ratings +$9 shipping Listed 1 month ago

Theory's zip-front A-line in a weave more considered than their standard jersey — on the market for a brand whose resale following never matched its retail footprint.

6.0 /10

Theory $51 $345–$425$425(87% Off Est. Retail87% Off Est Retail)

Theory Dress Womens 2 Black Geometric Jacquard Sheath Half Sleeve Knee Length

99.9% · 3,394 ratings +$9 shipping Listed 2 months ago

Theory's jacquard sheath is what the brand built its reputation on—structured office dressing that reads intentional rather than basic, a reference point other labels still imitate.

6.0 /10

Theory $52 $395–$495$495(88% Off Est. Retail88% Off Est Retail)

Theory Black Jersey Knit Short Sleeve Little Black Dress Size XS ( 0 - 2) EUC

98.0% · 1,548 ratings +$9 shipping Listed 11 months ago

Theory's jersey shift, seven months on the market — the ask has drifted toward where contemporary basics start rather than where this brand clears.

6.0 /10

Theory $60 $225–$275$275(76% Off Est. Retail76% Off Est Retail)

Theory Women's Good Wool Eano Sheath Dress Size 6 Dark Cement

100.0% · 180 ratings Free shipping Listed 16 months ago

Theory's Good Wool sheath—the cut that defined early-aughts office dressing—here where the specific color name keeps it from buyers who search the label.

6.0 /10

Theory $69 $395–$425$425(83% Off Est. Retail83% Off Est Retail)

Theory Women's 100% Silk Shift Dress Size 6 Black Long Puff Sleeve Sz P

100.0% · 500 ratings +$9 shipping Listed 13 months ago

Theory's silk shift is the cut that made the brand the reference point for office-to-evening minimalism—here in the puff-sleeve variation that reads more statement than standard.

6.0 /10

Theory $60 $295–$345$345(81% Off Est. Retail81% Off Est Retail)

Theory Deep Purple Midi Wool Dress Women's Size 0 Minimalist Chic Quiet Luxury

99.0% · 144 ratings Free shipping Listed 9 months ago

Theory's minimalist wool midis are the reference point for American quiet luxury—this one has been waiting months because the audience for this cut is thinner than you'd expect.

6.0 /10

Theory $65 $295–$395$395(81% Off Est. Retail81% Off Est Retail)

THEORY Jasneah Wool Blend Lined Mini Shift Dress Gray Herringbone 6

100.0% · 3,729 ratings Free shipping Listed 9 months ago

A mainline Theory wool-blend shift in excellent condition sitting well under the usual secondary floor for the brand's dresses.

6.0 /10

Theory $65 $295–$345$345(80% Off Est. Retail80% Off Est Retail)

No deals match your filters.

Try broadening your search, or run a new search to surface more picks.

Buying Secondhand Theory Dresses

Theory dresses are a sensible, low-drama secondhand buy: modestly priced, widely available, and easy to assess. The brand names its better fabrics, and that habit carries over from the tailoring -- so a quick look at the label separates the pieces worth having from the ordinary stretch blends.

Affordable and Well-Supplied

Theory dresses sell for modest money and surface frequently, so there's no need to settle. The sheath and jersey styles are office staples that get resold in good condition, and the minimalist cuts don't read as dated across seasons -- which makes older listings just as viable as recent ones.

Fabric and Condition

A named Theory fabric wears and drapes better than a poly-heavy blend, and the label is the tell since the two can sell at similar prices. On condition, check jersey and knit styles at the hips and underarms for pilling, look for any sheen on crepe at stress points, and check silk styles for underarm staining.

Theory Dress Questions

How much do Theory dresses cost secondhand?

Modest money -- among the more affordable dresses from a recognizable name, and they turn up often, so there's rarely a reason to overpay for average condition.

Which Theory dresses are worth buying used?

The sheath, jersey, and crepe styles in good condition, ideally in a named Theory fabric rather than a generic stretch blend. The minimalist cuts don't date, so older pieces are still viable.

What condition issues affect used Theory dresses?

Pilling on jersey and knit styles at the hips and underarms, sheen on crepe at stress points, and underarm staining on silk. These are the variables that separate a good buy from a tired one.

Theory Dresses

No deals match your filters.

Buying Secondhand Theory Dresses

Affordable and Well-Supplied

Fabric and Condition

Theory Dress Questions

Explore More